A request for quotation (RFQ) that lists cyclopentasiloxane (D5) and dimethicone as alternates on one line looks like a way to widen the bid. It is a formulation change made by purchasing. One of the two silicones is meant to evaporate from the product within hours of application; the other is meant to stay on the skin or hair as the film. Approve the lower quote, and your lot can pass every incoming check while the batch misses its sensory target.
Cyclopentasiloxane vs dimethicone: which one stays in the film?
Dimethicone stays; cyclopentasiloxane evaporates. Cyclopentasiloxane (D5, CAS 541-02-6) is a volatile cyclic silicone, and the 2016 opinion of the EU Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety (SCCS) records that it evaporates from skin or hair within 4-12 hours after application. Dimethicone (CAS 9006-65-9) is a linear polymer, and its film-forming grades stay on the surface after the D5 has evaporated.
They work as a pair. D5 is the vehicle: it spreads a product, carries heavier ingredients to where they are wanted and then evaporates. Dimethicone is the payload, the slip and shine that remain once the vehicle has gone. A specification that treats one as a cheaper version of the other asks a carrier to be a film, or a film to dry.
Cyclomethicone is a class name for cyclic dimethylsiloxanes, so “cyclomethicone vs dimethicone” is the same comparison at class level. And the dimethicone name covers a whole viscosity range: the lowest-viscosity linear grades, such as a 2 cSt volatile dimethicone, evaporate too, so “dimethicone” below means the film-forming grades. If an RFQ lists D5 and dimethicone as alternates, send it back to the formulator before it goes to bid.
Why does D5 evaporate if it boils at 210 °C?
D5’s boiling point, 210 °C, is where its vapor pressure reaches atmospheric pressure, not the temperature at which it “flashes off”. On skin, what counts is vapor pressure at skin temperature. The PubChem record for D5 (CID 10913) lists 0.2 mmHg, and 0.3 mmHg at 25 °C by OECD Guideline 104.
That higher figure is a straight-line extrapolation from measurements above room temperature, and it is higher than other reported values: the Environment Agency (England and Wales) cites 0.174 mmHg at 25 °C in its 2009 assessment, and a gas-chromatographic study in the ECHA registration dossier gives 20.4 Pa (about 0.15 mmHg) at 25 °C.
A study summarized in the same PubChem record measured evaporation from leave-on products under realistic exposure conditions. On an aluminum test surface, neat D5 evaporated at a mean 0.029 mg per cm² per minute at 23 °C and 0.060 mg per cm² per minute at 32 °C. That is about 35 and 17 minutes per mg/cm² applied. The largest formulation effect in that study was a 2-fold decrease in rate, for a face cream at 32 °C.
No heat is needed. In a 2023 test-house study in Environmental Science & Technology, a hair oil with D5 as its first ingredient, applied by hand, still released 420 mg of D5 per person. The authors put that down to D5’s volatility at room temperature. In antiperspirants, an industry-association study cited by Canada’s Board of Review for D5 (2011) found less than 1% of the applied D5 left for wash-off after eight hours and less than 0.1% after 24 hours.
The 4-12 hour window in SCCS opinion SCCS/1549/15 is the applicant’s statement as the committee summarized it, with no application amount, product or temperature. The European Chemicals Agency (ECHA) lists the cyclics as conditioning agents and solvents or diluents in its 2019 restriction report, and credits their rapid product drying to high volatility. Run drying-time checks on a carrier lot at skin temperature as well as at bench temperature, because the measured rate about doubles between 23 °C and 32 °C.
What does dimethicone do that D5 cannot?
Dimethicone is a polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS), (C2H6OSi)n, and the n carries the specification. It has no single molecular weight; chain length varies from grade to grade, which is why it is bought by viscosity. Published cosmetic studies alone use 2 cSt, 50 cSt, 100 cSt and 350 cSt grades. Longer chains mean lower vapor pressure, so the grades bought for conditioning stay where D5 evaporates.
In hair care, a 2015 review in the International Journal of Trichology calls dimethicone the most widely used silicone. Being hydrophobic, it adsorbs better on virgin hair than on the tips, and products for damaged hair add cationic bridging agents to raise its affinity.
A list quoted in the Danish Environmental Protection Agency’s 2005 siloxanes report draws the line for hair-styling products: dimethicone for softness and shine, volatile silicones for reduced tack, shorter drying time and “transitory shine”. Order dimethicone by viscosity grade, and name on the RFQ the grade the formula was developed with.
Dimethicone vs cyclopentasiloxane, property by property
D5 values are PubChem’s (CID 10913) unless another source is named.
| Property | Cyclopentasiloxane (D5) | Dimethicone |
|---|---|---|
| CAS number | 541-02-6 | 9006-65-9 |
| Structure | Cyclic pentamer, C10H30O5Si5 | Linear polymer, (C2H6OSi)n |
| Molecular weight | 370.77 g/mol | No single value; varies with chain length |
| Boiling point | 210 °C | Grade-specific; read the technical data sheet (TDS) |
| Vapor pressure | 0.2 mmHg; 0.3 mmHg at 25 °C (OECD Guideline 104), an extrapolation; other reported values: 0.174 mmHg (Environment Agency, 2009) and 20.4 Pa (ECHA dossier) at 25 °C | Grade-specific; the 2 cSt grade is volatile, film-forming grades are not |
| Density | 0.9593 g/cm³ at 20 °C | Read the TDS |
| Solubility in water | 1.7 × 10⁻² mg/L at 25 °C | Insoluble (Journal of Cutaneous and Aesthetic Surgery, 2023) |
| Flash point | 73 °C, closed cup | Grade-specific; read the safety data sheet (SDS) |
| Time on skin or hair | Evaporates within 4-12 hours (SCCS opinion, applicant’s statement) | Film-forming grades remain as the film |
| Job in the formula | Carrier, solvent or diluent, volatile emollient | Film former, conditioning agent, slip, foam reduction in emulsions (Danish EPA, 2005) |
| Residual cyclics | D4 possibly above 0.1% but below 1% (U.S. EPA draft, 2025) | 1-3% as sums in higher-molecular-weight polymers (Canada, 2008); D4 and D5 typically below 0.1% (ECHA, 2019) |
| What the RFQ must name | INCI name, CAS, assay, maximum D4 | INCI name, CAS, viscosity grade, maximum D4, D5 and D6 |
Carry the last row into the RFQ as written; set the residual-cyclics maxima with the calculation in the section on replacing D5 with dimethicone.
Why do cyclopentasiloxane and dimethicone appear together on an ingredient list?
Because one carries the other. The 2023 Environmental Science & Technology study describes cyclic volatile siloxanes as carriers that deliver high-molecular-weight fluids uniformly to hair. It notes that D5 is often listed first or second on some hair care ingredient lists.
Read an INCI list such as “cyclopentasiloxane, dimethicone, dimethiconol” or “cyclopentasiloxane and dimethicone crosspolymer” that way: the heavier silicones arrive in a volatile carrier. Dimethiconol is one of the silicones a 2015 review in the Indian Journal of Dermatology lists as synthetic oils in hair conditioners, used for film formation, shine and luster. Dimethicone crosspolymers, in a 2014 Cosmetic Ingredient Review of 62 such ingredients, work as film formers, slip modifiers and nonaqueous viscosity-increasing agents, among other functions. Apply the blend and the D5 evaporates; the polymer stays.
A pre-blend, such as a multi-component silicone blend built on cyclopentasiloxane, puts the carrier and the polymer in one lot. Composition varies from blend to blend, so write it into the RFQ line: the D5 share, the polymer and its viscosity, and the maximum D4.
The silicones in cosmetics selection guide covers how the other cosmetic silicones divide the work. When a formula or a pre-blend names both, write the carrier and the polymer into the spec separately, even when they arrive as one lot.
Does replacing D5 with dimethicone take D5 out of the formula?
No. Canada’s 2008 screening assessment of D5 states that all PDMS polymers contain residual volatile cyclosiloxanes, D5 among them: lower-viscosity polymers may contain <0.1% to 0.5% and higher-molecular-weight polymers 1-3%, as sums of cyclics.
ECHA’s 2019 Annex XV restriction report puts typical D4 and D5 in silicone polymers bought by cosmetics formulators below 0.1%, but records residual D5 that might reach 1-2% in certain polymers, especially emulsion polymers. It adds that polymers with “zero content” of D4, D5 and D6 cannot be made with conventional production techniques. Plan to the higher figures until a lot’s certificate of analysis (CoA) shows otherwise; both agencies describe typical polymers, Canada in 2008 and ECHA in 2019.
The D5 a dimethicone adds to a formula is its residual D5 times its use level. At a 10% use level, a polymer carrying 1% residual D5, the low end of ECHA’s range, adds 0.1% D5 to the finished product. ECHA reasons the same way, noting that mixtures made from polymers with more than 0.1% residual D4, D5 and D6 may contain less than 0.1% in the final product after dilution.
To set each cap, divide the finished-product target by the dimethicone’s share of the formula, and keep that target below 0.1% for each of D4, D5 and D6 after adding the D5 from every other ingredient that carries it: the 1%-residual polymer in the example reaches 0.1% on its own.
The EU restriction sets the limit that target must stay under. REACH Annex XVII entry 70, as replaced by Commission Regulation (EU) 2024/1328 of 16 May 2024, has two dates for cosmetics. Paragraph 3(a) reads: “for D4 and D5 in wash-off cosmetic products, paragraph 1, point (c), shall apply after 31 January 2020.” Paragraph 3(b) reads: “for all cosmetic products other than the ones mentioned in paragraph 3(a), paragraph 1 shall apply after 6 June 2027;”.
For wash-off products the prohibition covers D4 and D5 at 0.1% w/w or more. After 6 June 2027 it reaches D4, D5 and D6 at 0.1% w/w or more in all other cosmetic products, leave-on included. That covers D5 used as the carrier as well as residues from the dimethicone. The restriction’s scope is covered in D5 safety and the EU restriction. If an EU leave-on product relies on D5 as its carrier, qualify the replacement carrier and start its sensory panel now.
The D5 lot needs the same attention: the U.S. EPA’s September 2025 public-release draft risk evaluation for D4 relays that D4 may be present in D5 at more than 0.1% but below 1%. Cap D4 on the D5 line and have each lot’s CoA report it.
What can replace D5 as the carrier?
The Danish EPA’s 2005 report, from supplier interviews on soaps and leave-on lotions and creams, singled out cyclomethicone as especially difficult to substitute and found dimethicone generally easier to replace with vegetable oils. Its summary is broader: in emulsions and creams, cyclomethicone and dimethicone were both especially difficult to replace, because alternatives lack their foam-reducing effect. In shampoos, water-insoluble dimethicone can also reduce lather (Journal of Cutaneous and Aesthetic Surgery, 2023).
In a six-person supplier test the Danish report cites, all six panelists rated a cream based on cyclopentasiloxane better for spreadability and soft feel than one based on diethylhexyl carbonate. A 2023 molecular-dynamics study in Polymers selected triheptanoin with C13 isoalkane as a D5 substitute pair by simulation. Treat any carrier change as a reformulation with its own sensory panel, and check foam wherever a silicone-free ingredient replaces a silicone.
What should the specification and RFQ say?
Write each silicone line around its job, then name the grade that does it:
-
Name the job. Write “carrier, must evaporate” or “film former, must stay”. If the formula needs both, write two lines, or one pre-blend line that states its composition: the D5 share, the polymer and its viscosity, and the maximum D4.
-
Specify the carrier line. Give INCI cyclopentasiloxane, CAS 541-02-6, a minimum assay and a maximum D4, each reported on the lot’s CoA. Do not accept “cyclomethicone” on the CoA in place of a ring-by-ring result.
-
Specify the film line. Give INCI dimethicone, CAS 9006-65-9 and the viscosity grade with its test temperature; one CAS number spans the whole viscosity range.
-
Cap residual cyclics in the dimethicone. Set separate D4, D5 and D6 maxima from the use-level arithmetic above. A published headspace gas-chromatography method (2020) reaches a detection limit of 0.0025% m/m for D3-D5 in finished personal care products; it does not cover D6 or neat polymer. ECHA notes that polymers can break down to low levels of D4, D5 and D6 under some conditions, such as high temperatures. Ask the supplier which method and detection limit it uses for each of D4, D5 and D6 in the polymer.
-
State the market and the product type. Say whether the product is wash-off or leave-on and whether it will be sold in the EU. Under entry 70 of REACH Annex XVII (Regulation (EU) 2024/1328, 16 May 2024), an EU leave-on product’s D5 carrier line needs a qualified replacement before 6 June 2027.
-
Ask for the current SDS and TDS for each grade. Flash point decides how a lot is stored and shipped: D5’s is 73 °C (closed cup), and a polymer grade’s is on its own SDS. Take each figure, and the classification that follows from it, from that grade’s current sheet.
Methodology: D5 property values and the bench evaporation study are from PubChem (CID 10913); every other figure comes from the regulatory documents and peer-reviewed studies named in the text, and none is a RawSource measurement.
Frequently asked questions
Is cyclomethicone the same thing as cyclopentasiloxane?
Does heat styling change how fast D5 leaves the hair?
Can a volatile dimethicone replace cyclopentasiloxane?
How high do use levels run for each silicone?
Sources & methodology
Figures are RawSource sourcing data unless attributed to a named source. Regulatory citations are current as of publication. Chemical identities verified by CAS number against the RawSource catalog.
Search 1,300+ industrial chemicals by name or CAS, or send us your spec — we quote by the drum, tote, or container.
Browse the Chemical Index → Request a Quote